Has the mansion tax finally died?
Monday, February 27th, 2012There has been much speculation in the media in recent weeks about one of Nick Clegg’s favourite political goals – a ‘super council tax’ or ‘mansion tax’ – being included within George Osborne’s budget, due to be revealed next month.
Details of the tax have always been hard to establish but properties worth over either £1 million or £2 million would pay an extra 1% tax, collected by local authorities via the council tax. So the owner of a home worth £1 million face an additional duty of £10,000 and for a £2 million property £20,000 and so on up the scale.
It is understandable why the collation would want to raise such a tax at a time when the government’s budget has yet to be balanced, but is it a practical way to raise the funds?
At first the figures look promising. According to estate agent Knight Frank there are 155,000 homes in the UK worth over £1 million, which would help Osborne raise at least £1.55 billion. On the other hand there are 42,000 homes worth £2 million or more, which would raise at least £840 million.
The word mansion tax is misleading, of course. Many of Britain’s £1 million homes are not huge piles but apartments, bungalows and terraced Victorian houses. For example, in the London Borough of Westminster there are 630 million-pound homes for sale, of which 430 are flats. And in Buckinghamshire there are 540 million-pound homes, of which half are what many might call ‘ordinary’ three or four bedroom houses.
One other concern has been who owns these properties. While many are wealthy families, some are not and those opposing the mansion tax say the property rich (but income poor) will be unfairly punished by it; for the crime of having not moved to a smaller house beforehand.
Lastly, many say a mansion tax would be difficult and expensive to collect. Local government data on how much homes are worth – i.e. council tax bands – are extremely out of date and last calculated in 1991, so the cost of working which homes are really worth over £1 or £2 million would cost £200m, somewhat defeating the tax’s purpose.
Such arguments seem to have got through over the weekend. Yesterday, The Sunday Times quoted an anonymous Whitehall source who said Osborne would not be introducing a mansion tax after unrest within his party over the tax – a group headed up by the communities’ secretary Eric Pickles, who has opposed it since at least August 2011.























