David Ross: making a bad call on a Yorkshire village?
Monday, May 9th, 2011PrimeLocation recently paid a visit to Rosedale Abbey in North Yorkshire and was surprised to discover a hornet’s nest of unhappy home owners rather than the genteel moorland community one might expect.
Tempers are getting frayed over proposals to turn a defunct pub into a boarding house for wayward youth from nearby Grimsby. But why would this interest a wider audience?
Firstly, The Milburn Arms, as it was known until closing in 2008, is owned by multimillionaire and Tory party donor David Ross, best known as founder of mobile phone firm Carphone Warehouse. But what’s really stirring up local passions is their fight for a place to gather, something that touches a raw nerve in the thousands of small communities across the UK facing reduced services. For example, last year 1,300 pubs closed down and this year 1,000 village stores face closure as the recession bites.
The Milburn Arms story started when Ross, flush with the millions he made from Carphone Warehouse, bought the Rosedale Estate, a shooting estate that once belonged to one of the North East’s richest mining and shipping families, the Milburns – and after which the pub is named.
The pub is part of the estate but the business had been going badly for its landlord, who had paid £100,000 for it in 1983 and coughed up £27,500 a year in rent, Land Registry enquiries reveal.

David Ross pictured with (from LtoR) former wife Shelly, David and Samantha Camera at the 2006 Conservative Party Summer Party in London.
In the 2008 The Milburn Arms closed down and this is when the fun started. The estbalishment, which is really a hotel, pub and restaurant rolled into one, was then mooted by Ross as an extension of the Havelock Academy, a school in Grimsby he helps fund. The hotel would have then become the residential block for children from the academy attending outward-bound style courses in the surrounding North York Moors.
Locals, including celebrity glass blower Gillies Jones, believe Ross isn’t keen to find another landlord for the pub while a change of use application for an educational establishment is prepared for the local council – something that Ross, who is said to have a ‘personal interest’ in The Milburn Arms, denies.
In the meantime, one of Yorkshire’s most famous villages favoured by walkers, mountain bikers and tourists has only two small tea shops, no pub and, ironically, PrimeLocation noticed while there, very little mobile phone coverage.


















